It is unsurprising that one of the strongest items in Stardew Valley is hard to obtain, with a cryptic clue providing the only relevant in-game information. Of course, Stardew Valley is full of secrets, but this particular puzzle is among the games oldest, while the reward remains one of its best despite changes made through later updates. As a result, although it is possible to expedite matters with prior knowledge, the intended method of obtaining this item undoubtedly adds an extra layer of fun to the later stages of the game.